Discussion Underrated Pornstar(s), Overrated Pornstar(s) & Why

[Antiquarianes]

Please, Log in or Register to view quotes

Not sure if 'outfuck' is the most appropriate word but as a non-fan I must admit it: she was great in How the Grinch Stole Christmas.

Spoiler

Please, Log in or Register to view spoilers

Just kidding, I agree with you, as I said I'm not a fan at all but she was physically (and moreover aesthetically) very unconventional and that's probably how she was so famous and could became such a long-serving vet.

 

[Mikediamond]

Please, Log in or Register to view quotes

PETA Jensen.. so hot, content not so much

 

[DaVinci]

Is there a US ONLY hidden somewhere on this thread title that i missed? Dont get me wrong i agree with you all with the most overrated US pornstar picks(except Riley, that girl is a nympho since the moment she hit puberty and that rape story is just pornstars not being the sharpest tool in the shed), but we need more non US love in this thread:


Overrated

US

the usual suspects Angela, Adriana, Abella , Sasha Grey, OK ass but super fake performance and verbal use(go watch 5 minutes of her twich stream and you'll know how much she overacted) Veronica Avluv, Anna de Villle, AJ Applegate, Remy Lacroix.

NON US

Veronica Leal, Timea Bella, Emily Pink, Brittany Bardot, Jia Lissa(she is ok and the scenes with Liya Sliver and Ella Hughes are dope but i just dont get her solo appeal since she so average looking IMO) Amirah Adara, Jasmine Jae, Aletta Ocean(same as Lana Rhoades, fell to unnecessary cosmetic surgery sickness)

Underrated

US

Ashley Lane, Sabrina Banks, Anya Olsen, Kimberly Kane, Lily Carter, Luna Kitsuen, Ashley Adams, Karla Kush, Cadence Lux, Callie Calypso, Crystal Rae, Sierra Sanders, Natalie Moore, Christina Brooks, Nikki Rhodes , Leah Winters.

NON US

Vittoria Dolce, Kelly Oliveira, , Kira Parvati, July Sun, Linda Sweet, Vicky Sol (perfect greek ass) Licky Lex, Dolly Dyson(german nympho), Tigerr benson(cute asian bimbo) Nicole Black, Natalie Cherry, Kany, Lina Love, Cayenne, Stacy Snake, Shona River.

 

[DJ Horny Devil]

Please, Log in or Register to view quotes

 

[hottrashbot]

Please, Log in or Register to view quotes

I'm sure I know of a lot of porn stars that mostly perform in the US but are technically foreign. A few I know of that I wish I saw more mainstream (I don't know if that really meets the criteria of "underrated" for the purposes of this thread but wth, I'll throw their names in):

Please, Log in or Register to see links and images

(not as fond of her now but I like her earlier work),

Please, Log in or Register to see links and images

(LOVED her Public Pick Ups bar scene), and

Please, Log in or Register to see links and images

(honestly love everything I've seen her do).

As a side note, is there an easy way to do a head count in this thread?? I'd really like to know how many times some of the frequent flyers like Mia Khalifa and Riley Reid have been brought up and in what context.

 

[Longdick98]

Please, Log in or Register to view quotes

yea https://simpcity.su/threads/volcanicblossom-pufffypink.20508/

 

[staralfur]

Please, Log in or Register to view quotes

Vanessa Leon is the only other porn actress with the same young Lela Star vibes, Vanessa, Lela and Jenaveve were my favourite 3 growing up then Lela Star did that tragic thing with herself.

 

[Cornelius4129]

I'm not going to say she's overrated but I haven't liked anything Alexis Fawx has put out in a long time.

 

[thebigbangashley]

Ashley lane is definitely the most underrated star

 

[Desperados]

going by ph top models, overrated:

Riley reid - imo body below mid, face mid
Lana rhoades - her face is not it for me
Elsa jean - best marketing in the business, surely. Choosing the name elsa right at the top of frozen’s popularity was genius. But idk her face…
Skye blue with short hair - the pixie cut does NOT work for her
Angela White - barely overrated; this seems to be controversial. Shes so ubiquitous that some of the scenes starring her are truly horrible, but she collabs a lot with other people. Say what you want about her, but good chance theres someone you like whos collabed with her, and i dont think she ever detracts from a scene
Kendra sunderland- in the old days she was the best, then she went full bimbo
Eva elfie - her moans are not it

Appropriately rated:
Mia Malkova: barely in appropriate rated, leaning towards overrated. I watched her plug talk and idk her natural sounding voice changed something. But a lot of her vids she needs to calm down
Angel youngs: great up and comer
Jazlyn ray: maybe even slightly under rated


Underrated
Mia melano: politics aside she’s the perfect girl next door
Skye blue with long hair - phenomenal


obviously all my own opinion, and imo it really depends on what scene. Like angela white in the library scene and some others goes from overrated to underrated. Mia melano in most main stream production is overrated, but her other stuff is great.

Also im only rating if a girl is cast in main stream porn - so not amouranth, dainty wilder, etc. etc. because suddenly youre going from like 100 girls to thousands and thats even more subjective

 

[longpiper]

Please, Log in or Register to view quotes

Emma magnolia looks dirty to me, ever since she said she didnt shower in an interview..

 

[RambleTop]

Someone who is Overrated is that Shrooms Q girl. I do not understand the appeal of her. She is super underweight, with a flat chest and a long back with no ass. She also has some of the worst tattoos I have seen on a porn star in a while. She has a blacked out heart with horns on her ass and badly tattooed thorns or some shit on her hands.

 

[drdd75]

Please, Log in or Register to view quotes

Ding Ding Ding!

I don't understand how she got popular so fast, and I never understood the appeal of underweight girls with no curves at all. There are other ones out there too who blew up fast.

I will always be thankful for the thicc, busty and curvy pornstars and OF girls who give it their all on camera.

 

[lumberlord14]

Please, Log in or Register to view quotes

Have to agree with Charlotte Stokely, but if for nothing but her tongue (finest tongue since Keri Windsor); I'll watch Alina anytime.

 

[DappaMale]

Please, Log in or Register to view quotes

It's her sexual energy and facial expressions that makes her somewhat attractive.

 

[Wormant1]

overrated: Hitomi Tanaka

her eyes are atrocious and her boobs grotesque

 

[WASHED FRAUD]

Underrated: Kenzie Taylor
When I say Kenzie is underrated, I don't just mean she deserves to be properly rated. I mean she deserves to be up there with the GREATS.

I guess my biggest thing for her, oddly enough I know, is her personality.
She's always changing her style so she's always offering something different.
Doesn't seem to have any alcohol/drug abuse problems which is unfortunately common in the industry as well.
Also hasn't gone heavy with any enhancements (boobs which aren't bad and MAYBE lip fillers).
Most importantly she's been in the industry for quite a while and she seems to love what she does and is loved by her peers.

Please, Log in or Register to see links and images

P.S. Kenna James may be in the same boat as well

 

[BigChief0587]

Please, Log in or Register to view quotes

Definitely have an appreciation for Kenzie.
Overrated:
Mia Khalifa wouldn't be as fondly remembered if there were more stars from that same region/ethnicity. It gave her an exoticness a lot of people latched onto and she just isn't that good imo.
Elsa Jean was very pretty, fun to look at, but never really got sold into her performances.

Underrated:
Amber Moore, what a babe, love how she carries herself in her scenes. Was also happy to see she took Chloe Rose under her wing, there is potential there.
Blair Williams! That is a woman right there.

 

[WASHED FRAUD]

Overrated: Kayley Gunner

I loved Kayley at the start of her career when it was just the boob job, but as of now I'm not a fan of the recent surgeries.

The lipo REALLY SUCKS because she didn't even look that much different tbh. Like for being a vet you'd think she would've just CHAD that shit and worked out but she just opted for surgery. Her ass/hips just don't look natural anymore😭

I'm not a fan of the facial surgery either. She was gorgeous. She was really able have a "girl next door" look and ROCK an rbf. Now it's like her face is just set to one mode and that doesn't really appeal to me.

Reminds me a lot of Brooklyn Chase tbh. Like it's just obvious she went for the bimbo look which she didn't need to.

Please, Log in or Register to see links and images

Please, Log in or Register to see links and images

Please, Log in or Register to see links and images

Please, Log in or Register to see links and images

 

[WASHED FRAUD]

Bonus not-so overrated: Jewelz Blu and Kira Noir

Jewelz for almost the same reason as Kayley. I believe the only recent surgeries she had look to be for facial, which she DID NOT need.
Although similar body type to Kayley rn, you can tell her changes are natural and also look great on her.
I do miss the old Jewelz tho

For Kira, I wouldn't say she is overrated as a pornstar BUT I do think a hairstyle change is WELL PAST DUE at this point. Would love to see her let her down AT LEAST ONCE😭