Discussion Underrated Pornstar(s), Overrated Pornstar(s) & Why

EquivocalIndividual

Bathwater Drinker
Nov 14, 2022
59
5,981
1,252

Jbcv101

Bathwater Drinker
Jul 13, 2022
210
7,897
1,305
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
I’ll Begin:
Underrated: Mischa Brooks. Cute face with amazing eyes, good enough assets to be enticed by and was very diverse in the scenes she was involved in.

Overrated: Abella Danger. I don’t think she’s bad, but I never though to myself “I got to put on some Abella Danger”. Basic in many of her scenes to where I have clicked off watching her scenes. She doesn’t entice me enough to keep watching.
 

TripleIDoubleH

Bathwater Drinker
Nov 4, 2022
340
12,631
1,437
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Whatever, I mean, they are all cool and everything, however, but also I'll be solid in my choices so don't get offended that much or let it get to you, it's just my opinion, we have different tastes, also I'll add "Rated" and I'll list them like this, Males and Females, but here we go:

Males:
Overrated: Rocco Sifreddi (12 POTY AWARDS??!!), Keiran Lee, Mick Blue, Johnny Sins and Jordi (Both popularity due to internet memes made on them lol), Manuel Ferrara (His popularity is whatever) and Xander Corvus.
Rated: Lexington Steele, Danny D, Michael Stefano, Erik Everhard, Tommy Pistol and Steve Holmes.
Underrated: Dredd, Zac Wild, Tyler Nixon, Ramon Nomar, Mike Adriano, MrLuckypov, Prince Yahshua, Richard Mann and Chris Strokes.

Females:
Overrated: Belle Delphine, Sweetiefox, Eva Elfie, Asa Akira, Lana Rhoades, Mia Khalifa, Esparanza Gomez, Lasirena69 (seems kinda boring), Anikka Albrite (Booty doesn't look that jiggly), Kendra lust (sexy but not hottest Milf), Rachel Starr (Her ass isn't that sexy, also she doesn't wear small bikinis more often to make her body look that tasty), Savannah Bond (mid a bit), Angela White (Sexy but what's the deal with her about her? 6 times winner of best boobs?), Elsa Jean, Riley Reid, Piper Perri, Adriana Chechik, Tori Black, Kayden Kross, Sara Luvv and Xkaren Wife and almost every Spiegler girl.
Rated: Ava Addams, Violet Myers, Gianna Michaels, Valentina Nappi, Alexis Texas, Abella Danger, Jayden Jaymes, Sara Jay, Jane Wilde, Casey Calvert, Kagney, Jayden Jaymes, Siri Dahl, Hitomi Tanaka, Lisa Ann, Lena Paul, Lauren Phillips, Leana Lovings, Britney Amber, Kimberly Kane, Kira Noir, Bobbi Starr, Bridgette B, Phoenix Marie, Dana Dearmond, Dillion Harper, Remy Lacroix, A.J. Applegate, Gia Derza and Halle Hayes.
Underrated: Arabelle Raphael, Tricia Oaks, Abbey Brooks, Bella Rolland, Sophia Burns, Daisy Stone, Candice Dare, Layla Price, Jenna Starr, Ashley Lane, Erin Everheart, Adira Allure, Isabel Moon, Alison Tyler, Jada Stevens, Codi Vore, Paige Turnah, Jennifer White, Vicki Chase, Savannah Fox, Liza Del Sierra, Holly Michaels, Jessie Rogers, Alex Chance and Rebel Rhyder.

Maybe I could change my mind tho.
 
Last edited:

Jbcv101

Bathwater Drinker
Jul 13, 2022
210
7,897
1,305
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Underrated: Mason Moore. She is easily one of my top 10 favorite porn stars of all time. Especially when she was in her Prime years, had a nice body on the slimmer side. Phenomenal, perfect, big, round tits with a pussy I can't get enough of. She's one of the best and elite squirters of all time which is a huge turn on for me and her style of moaning & dirty talk imo is one of the best ever as well.

Overrated: Alexis Texas. Likely an unpopular opinion, but in the long list of PAWG pornstars, I would have her on the low part of that list. Not trying to be offensive but I find her to be one of the most unattractive women in the history of the industry. I also don't find her exciting to watch. She doesn't bring anything unique to her performances.
 

EquivocalIndividual

Bathwater Drinker
Nov 14, 2022
59
5,981
1,252
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Overrated:
  • Armani Black: I get it, she's got a pretty face, but let's not act like she doesn't have a horrible boob job and no ass. Again, something about her is very sexy but in my opinion she's very overrated
  • Please, Log in or Register to see links and images
    Please, Log in or Register to see links and images
    Please, Log in or Register to see links and images
    Please, Log in or Register to see links and images
Underrated:
 

3legsyndrome

Bathwater Drinker
Nov 4, 2023
80
5,781
502
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Overrated
Angela White - I really don't know what the fuss is with her. She does nothing for me. Just a Plain Jane with big tits.
Riley Reid - She irritates the erection out of me.
Abella Danger - I always thought she was a pompous individual and that has been confirmed by some interviews of other performers.
Alexis Texas - A butter face masked by a big ass.
Jessie Rogers - Is she coming or is she going? Does she hate porn or does she need the money? Confusion is not sexy.
Mia Malkova - Another big ass and that's it.
Carter Cruise - Irritating, boring and pompous bitch.
Nicole Aniston - ZZZZZZZZ
Lela Star - Keep that bitch far away from the fireplace because she may melt.
Brandi Love - Put a brown shopping bag over her head and its all good.

Underrated
Katrina Jade - I know many people are not fans of the tattoos but she is an excellent performer who really enjoys a good fucking. Sexy face, body and feet.
Keisha Grey - In her prime with that sexy gap-toothed smile and sexual prowess, she was a visual aphrodisiac.
Valentina Nappi - An exemplar of Mediterranean beauty, sensuality and sex-appeal.
Mandy Muse - At last, a big assed girl with a cute face to match and can actually ride dick with enthusiasm.
Kristina Rose - She was sexual dynamite in her prime.
Khloe Kapri - A cutie and very good performer.
Phoenix Marie - A total MILF sex-bomb with a legendary catalogue of dick-jerking scenes.
Scarlit Scandal - Ebony sex goddess. Her best work is on the Jules Jordan site.
Emma Hix - She just does something to me. Every scene of her's has me feeling like I have priapism.
 

MaxBiggie

Superfan
Dec 3, 2022
1
676
823
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Overrated - Kazumi, Emma Magnolia, Crystal Chase, Skylar Vox, Skye Blue, Maitland Ward, Sophia Leone, Brandi Love, Roxie Sinner, Lasirena, Kenzie Anne, Kenzie reeves, Alexis Texas, Nikki Benz, Mia Malkova, Mia Khalifa, Ava addams, Melody Marks, Kendra Sunderland, Leah Gotti, Abigail Morris,
Arabelle Rapahel, Kayley Gunner, Scarlett Jones. Elsa Jean

Properly Rated - Blake, Slimthick Vic,Hazel Moore,Vale Nappi, Angel Youngs, Keira Croft, Gia derza,Violet Myers, Violet Starr, Mona Azar, Paige Owens, Angela White, Tori Black, Alyx Star, Dani Daniels, Cory Chase, Emily willis, Adriana Chechik, Lauren Philips, Lisa Ann, Kendra Lust, Luna Star, Lily Lou, Jane wilde, Summer vixen, Savannah Bond, Jazlyn Ray,NicoleDoshi, Jen White, Kay Lovely, Valerica

Underrated - Carmela Clutch, Harley King, Eliza Ibarra, Jezebeth, Rebel Rhyder, Jackie Hoff, Lexi Grey, Kendra Heart, Leah winters, Angel Wicky, Chanel Grey, Minxx Marley, Khloe Kapri, Katie Kush, Savannah Sixx, Haley Spades, Mia Molotov, Andi Avalon, Elana Bunnz, Joslyn Jane, Aubree Valentine, Brenna Mckenna, Natalia Queen
 

saejima69

Tier 2 Sub
Jul 12, 2023
2
166
383
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Underrated:
Brooklyn Lee. She's an older pornstar (career lasted from 2010 - 2016?) but MAN she was fantastic. Unique and GORGEOUS face with a sexy figure. Her scenes were also always fantastic. She really gave it her all in every single scene and you'd be hard pressed to find a bad scene of hers.

Overrated:
Elsa Jean. I just don't understand the love she got/gets. Yeah she's a pretty girl (or she was but now she looks rough) but her scenes were always SUPER boring to me. I never understood the fascination with her when there's so many other petite blondes out there that were MUCH better than she ever was. To this day she's still very popular and I still just don't get it.
 

bokassa

Tier 2 Sub
Jan 28, 2023
1
183
380
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
That's a great topic idea !

To me :

Mia Khalifa is genuinely overrated I mean, I'm gonna get on some people bad side but I agree she has a pretty face OK. But what else ? Of course it's up on everybody's tastes but I don't find her gigantic breast so attractive.

Tori Mack is pretty underrated, she is now known under the name Tiana Blow and I must say she's pretty and cute, has a great butt. Probably a future BIG star.
 

Markarth13

Bathwater Drinker
Mar 11, 2022
78
2,172
1,242
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Overrated - Lana Rhoades, Mia Khalifa. Really a lot of the mega stars. Purely because of how boring they are, absolutely no passion just a pretty face

Underrated - Alina west, Feels like absolutely no one talks about her despite the fact that she puts on an amazing performance in what feels like every single scene. Yhivi would fall into the same category for me as well
 

talonred

Fan
Jul 30, 2022
12
70
229
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Underated: Charity Crawford (I wish she came back). I could not get enough of her. To me she was a natural, such a short career. Anya Olsen. come across as super fun. Feel like anyone could have a genuinly good time with her (not specifically in a sexual way).

Overrated: Adriana Chechik - Such a dull person. I've also watched her on Twitch, gaming. I don't watch her anymore, she sends me to sleep. Angela White - Are her massive boobs her personality? Becasue I dont see it otherwise.
 

kigulife

Tier 2 Sub
Jun 12, 2023
4
162
383
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Overrated: Piper Perri
Obviously a massive meme. She certainly knows her appeal, and rocks the braces and the twintails, but if all you want is a short girl you could do a lot better. Her face isn't great for one, and I don't see anything special in her performances.
maxresdefault.jpg


Underrated: Ash Hollywood
Beautiful tomboy goddess with a sweet soft voice what more could you want!
She was definitely willing to do some hardcore shit too, I wish she was still around.
ash-hollywood-girl.jpg
 

Sontarran

Tier 2 Sub
Feb 19, 2022
9
152
380
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Overrated
Mia Khalifa
: Where do I begin? She is one of the most bitter and hate filled ex porn actresses who uses her porn name to denounce the industry. She wants to lash out at men because she knows she will never be taken seriously by anyone she'd be attracted to. That she was young is no excuse for the decision to make fast money but at the cost of reduced mainstream career and relationship prospects and complain about it later.
Gianna Dior: I never got the appeal
Abella Danger: I don't think I've kept one scene where she was the only female performer. Looks are meh but her worst quality is her self importance. The chip on her shoulder is second only to that of Mia Khalifa.
Riley Reid: She literally admitted to raping a man
Alexis Texas: I wouldn't call her unattractive but her butt was the only thing keeping her in a job
Sara Jay: I wouldn't even call her a butterface. Her body isn't even all that.
Amirah Adara: Another case of "I just don't get it" with her.
Adriana Chechik: Cute girl next door looks but I didn't think much of her as a performer
Natasha Nice: She was cool initially but her best years are long behind her, especially with her weight gain. The fact that she added anal into her repertoire later on doesn't compensate.
Rachel Starr: Her scenes are 13 in a dozen
Bridgette B: I never understood what people saw in her. I never though she was anything special and doubt I ever will


Underrated
Aria Alexander: Digital Playground ruined her career with the contract. She always looked fun
Hazel Moore: Really pretty girl next door
Sydney Paige: She's on a mature side but I think she's one of the best looking performers
Helena Locke: She's mostly into fetish work, and is in her 40s but she was always fun for me to watch
Allison Wyte: She goes back a few years but there was something incredibly naughty about her
 

Aquilla

Bathwater Drinker
Feb 4, 2023
137
6,178
1,262
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
This is all very subjective. It's just everyone's opinions, subject to their own individual tastes.

I for one really like Abella Danger. Crazy amount of professional scenes to pick from, with lots of positions, thicker in her earlier years, fitter in the latter, many hair color changes... fit but not skinny, all natural, medium sized firm breasts, not too long not too short inner labia, nice b-hole too, hasn't gone the route of getting fake tits like most other performers do after a while...

I have no complaints. As far as I'm concerned she's solid on all fronts. Some people were saying her voice... I watch her do porn, not a podcast or ASMR, I couldn't care less about her voice.

As for overrated, rather than mentioning professional stars like Angela White or Riley Reid who at the end of the day at least deliver something (in their case, plenty, actually), I'd go with all the cockteasing thots with discussion threads with hundreds of pages on this site full of people whining about how they do nothing but lie and never deliver. Some even have huge fandoms and they've never even shown any nudity at all . Insane that people go wild over that; I thought the name of this forum was ironic when I first joined, I've come to realize it's actually a very honest description.

But of course that's nothing but subjective. One man's trash is another man's treasure as they say.
 

ThePervyCosmic

Tier 3 Sub
Mar 11, 2022
47
455
512
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Underrated:

April O'Neil. All natural & she has only gotten naturally thick over the years and does not have a Mewtwo body. She managed to stay humble in the industry & her scenes seems authentic over most other preformers. She seems to put out less scenes way before the OF trend. Always speaks to her fans on her OF & social media since Day 1.

Dillion Harper. Was moderately famous. Did a porn star stripper tour from late 2017-2019. She has gotten naturally thick too recently, but has been shunned by some fans because of it. Content from her has been scarced since.

Mia Li/Mia Little. She had a good rise in the industry making a name for herself. Did scenes for Kink & Wrestling Fetish videos. Once she said she did not want to do Asian fetish scenes/movies, her content came to a halt. Has her own blog & shoots content on others OF/sites since.

Mia Valentine. Highly Underrated! Started off as a camgirl. Shoots content for Playboy & Art Galleries. Also DJs. Was mostly a GG/Solo preformer. Now shoots more B/G content then ever. Also speaks to her fans on her OF.

Overrated:

Amouranth/Scamoranth: Overcharges and false advertising her content for badly shot POVs & B/G content with someone standing in using a realistic dildo. I would respect her more IF she was honest about the content she makes.


Mia Khalifa. Was all about the exposure in the beginning, turned her back & bad mouths the industry. Now overcharges for non-nude content worse than Scamoranth.

Violet Myers: Big Boobs, and suddenly got an ass she didn't have when she started. Might be BBL procedure. She is shooting all kind of content across the industry to stay relevant. Scenes have been lackluster since her popularity improved.

Tessa Fowler: Blew up due to her big boobs on Cosmid, made a career on PinUpFiles, moved to OF to make her own solo stuff. Throughout her career since joining PUF, has been inconsistent. Disappears for weeks at a time. She has been inactive on OF pushing 8 months, but still signs on to collect her subscription payments from those that are still subscribed.
 
Last edited:

hotdog_6961

Tier 1 Sub
Dec 30, 2022
3
145
380
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Please, Log in or Register to view quotes

Great shout on Mischa Brooks. She was fantastic and knew how to ride a dick. I also agree Abella Danger is very overrated. I liked her at first but then she just seemed to be everywhere.

On that same note...

Overrated: Angela White
Yea I get it, she has big tits. She seems to be everywhere and her scenes don't really do it for me.

Underrated: Lola Foxx
No idea what happened to her, I know she gained some weight by the end of her career but she had that cute teen look with a bubble butt down, and don't feel like she really ever broke out as too popular.