Discussion Underrated Pornstar(s), Overrated Pornstar(s) & Why

Jbcv101

Bathwater Drinker
Jul 13, 2022
210
7,860
1,305
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
I created this thread to begin a discussion of a Pornstar(s) (Retired or Active) you believe has never received the recognition or praise she deserves as well as a Pornstar(s) (Retired or Active) you believe has gotten too much recognition and praise or simply never understood the hype that Pornstar(s) receives.

Feel free to give reason(s) why you feel that way.
 
Last edited:

Jbcv101

Bathwater Drinker
Jul 13, 2022
210
7,860
1,305
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
I’ll Begin:
Underrated: Mischa Brooks. Cute face with amazing eyes, good enough assets to be enticed by and was very diverse in the scenes she was involved in.

Overrated: Abella Danger. I don’t think she’s bad, but I never though to myself “I got to put on some Abella Danger”. Basic in many of her scenes to where I have clicked off watching her scenes. She doesn’t entice me enough to keep watching.
 

saejima69

Tier 2 Sub
Jul 12, 2023
2
161
383
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Underrated:
Brooklyn Lee. She's an older pornstar (career lasted from 2010 - 2016?) but MAN she was fantastic. Unique and GORGEOUS face with a sexy figure. Her scenes were also always fantastic. She really gave it her all in every single scene and you'd be hard pressed to find a bad scene of hers.

Overrated:
Elsa Jean. I just don't understand the love she got/gets. Yeah she's a pretty girl (or she was but now she looks rough) but her scenes were always SUPER boring to me. I never understood the fascination with her when there's so many other petite blondes out there that were MUCH better than she ever was. To this day she's still very popular and I still just don't get it.
 

hitmanboy47

Tier 3 Sub
Oct 9, 2022
11
412
604
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Nice initiative, although I would have removed the 1-1 limit anyway:

Underrated:
Sincerre LeMore

I discovered her in a scene with Joey Brass and was sorry to see that her pornographic career was very short.
To me she had a great body and possessed great sexual intensity.

Overrated:
Jesse Jane

I don't want to discuss how famous she is, we are in the jenna jameson years, and how much she will surely be appreciated by many of you in this forum.

Sure, a very provocative blonde however what has never convinced me is the way she approaches a sex scene: too unnatural for my taste.

She seemed to have multiple orgasms in bursts. For me this is a case of overacting.
 

Jbcv101

Bathwater Drinker
Jul 13, 2022
210
7,860
1,305
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Underrated: Mason Moore. She is easily one of my top 10 favorite porn stars of all time. Especially when she was in her Prime years, had a nice body on the slimmer side. Phenomenal, perfect, big, round tits with a pussy I can't get enough of. She's one of the best and elite squirters of all time which is a huge turn on for me and her style of moaning & dirty talk imo is one of the best ever as well.

Overrated: Alexis Texas. Likely an unpopular opinion, but in the long list of PAWG pornstars, I would have her on the low part of that list. Not trying to be offensive but I find her to be one of the most unattractive women in the history of the industry. I also don't find her exciting to watch. She doesn't bring anything unique to her performances.
 

bokassa

Tier 1 Sub
Jan 28, 2023
1
142
380
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
That's a great topic idea !

To me :

Mia Khalifa is genuinely overrated I mean, I'm gonna get on some people bad side but I agree she has a pretty face OK. But what else ? Of course it's up on everybody's tastes but I don't find her gigantic breast so attractive.

Tori Mack is pretty underrated, she is now known under the name Tiana Blow and I must say she's pretty and cute, has a great butt. Probably a future BIG star.
 

hotdog_6961

Tier 1 Sub
Dec 30, 2022
3
144
380
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Please, Log in or Register to view quotes

Great shout on Mischa Brooks. She was fantastic and knew how to ride a dick. I also agree Abella Danger is very overrated. I liked her at first but then she just seemed to be everywhere.

On that same note...

Overrated: Angela White
Yea I get it, she has big tits. She seems to be everywhere and her scenes don't really do it for me.

Underrated: Lola Foxx
No idea what happened to her, I know she gained some weight by the end of her career but she had that cute teen look with a bubble butt down, and don't feel like she really ever broke out as too popular.
 

hitmanboy47

Tier 3 Sub
Oct 9, 2022
11
412
604
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Please, Log in or Register to view quotes
It seems to me that Mia Khalifa got all this attention for wearing the hijab. What's more, her porn career has not been a positive experience according to her statements.
Nevertheless her short career has been her launching pad into popularity.

Then in my opinion we need to scale back the word pornstar: to me it means a porn actor/actress who has had either a long or short/medium successful career.
 

Mkit

Fan
Sep 3, 2022
1
61
325
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Overrated: I think Sasha Grey is a beautiful woman, but I can't stand watching her gag and slobber on a cock the way she does. That and her A cup chest, if she wasn't willing to do pretty much anything I don't think she would have been successful in porn. I do enjoy her twitch streams tho.

Underrated: similar name, and surprisingly similar look as well, Sasha Foxx. She's possibly trying to ride Grey's coattails to fame but watching her suck dick is a joy, talented, and enjoyable. Not to mention she actually has decent breasts. Most of her stuff seems to be with MHBHJ which is nice pov stuff, but there are other videos out there as well.
 

saejima69

Tier 2 Sub
Jul 12, 2023
2
161
383
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Please, Log in or Register to view quotes
I wouldn't say she was better looking than an average MODERN pornstar as a lot of them at this point look good compared to back in the day.

That being said she was cute at one point in time but in recent years she's started to look rough. It'd be different if she was naturally aging but she's gotten some work done on her face that's unfortunately ruined what the people DID like about her. My biggest issue with her was that I just always found her boring. She had no real personality and I always thought her videos were just...dull.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Lurker_007

mexdragon316

Tier 1 Sub
Dec 3, 2022
6
109
380
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Under:
- Molly Little (Love her eyes and I think she has a good chance of having a good career)
- Pristine Edge (There's not a lot of MILFs right now who have her body type)
- Siri Dahl (In my eyes, one of the most versatile actresses right now)
- Octavia Red (Smoking hot body and very nice tits, also I like her acting)
- Bunny Colby (There's something about her resting bitch face that makes me crazy)

Over:
- Maitland Ward (I don't get her whole "I'm a Hollywood actress" and being treated like royalty when her most memorable gig was being like 15 minutes in White Chicks. Also I think she exaggerates a lot in her scenes)
- Riley Reid (I didn't get the hype)
- Dani Daniels (I find her very attractive, but I feel her acting uninspiring)
- Kendra Sunderland (I liked her more before she went full bimbo)
- Brandi Love (Also I didn't get the hype)
 

LevisLover

Tier 3 Sub
May 30, 2023
26
359
534
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Please, Log in or Register to view quotes
I'm just bored of her, she's a solid marketeer for her content, but the actual content itself is mid. I said what I said. and I stand by it.

most of her scenes are shot on an iPhone, 1080p at best, and she overcharges for the content she puts out. her prices fluctuate depending on what day it is, almost as though the lunar calendar affects the price of a scene. take her "creampie with Jason Luv" scene for example.

I've had her DMs come through offering "discounted now" for her Jason Luv scene and seen it charged at $20, $15, $10 and even as low as $5

but if you message her asking for it, she'll reply with "Spoil me for it" or "Tip me $25 baby" and it's BS.

when you see the scene, it's hard to see them as it's grainy at times and her head is missing for the duration of the cowgirl, and the "creampie" isn't even even featured, he sounds like he's cumming, she sounds like she's getting it, she gives him a closing suck then it ends.

if it was a Blacked or JJ type scene, there would have been a 4K camera catching the whole scene, clear lighting, clear focus on them and the creampie finish would have been shown for everyone to enjoy. she's a "professional" who claims to be a producer, is self-shooting her own content and can't even put out a solid scene with one of the most talked-about male talents that she's shot with. I get she's trying the "amateur sextape" style vibe, but for $20 or so for the scene, this is just one example of why her content DEFINITELY not worth the price she's charging

and there's plenty more like it, she's overselling and underdelivering most of her content. but she's successful at pulling in the punters which is why she's a millionaire from it
 
Last edited: