I saw a recent pic of Aftyn last year can't really remember where but she seems to have fixed the gap teeth issue. Probably with the help of invisalign which a lot of these thots use to fix up their teeth.
I think physical appearance wise it's really close but personally I'd give the slight edge to Maimy. Maimy was my number one favorite years ago until I discovered more asmrtists with similar bodies but I still like Maimy. Just not as much as before.
Aftyn is hot in that for a white suburban girl next door type she has an amazing curvy body with a nice ass and big tits for her size. Plus she has nice looking soles, then again so does Maimy.
Maimy and Aftyn for me bodywise have nice bodies, ass, tits, and feet but I like Maimy's pasty skin color more and the color transition from the top of her feet to her red/orangey looking soles. Plus Maimy has those dimples too. Damn so did Aftyn. Just realize both these girls have dimples. Maybe that's part of their appeal lol
p_sailor has a point that I can see in Aftyn's videos in that her sexiness in her videos came off more natural and intimate than Maimy could pull off. She seems more like she was into the character she was portraying in her videos. Like she became those characters. Not to downplay Maimy cause Maimy is good to but not as naturally gifted.
I think both girls if they were to ever make a video physically together it will blow up the ASMR world. Damn imagine Aftyn (with fixed teeth) and Maimy kissing and touching each other while wearing bikinis and a silky laced top while sucking each others toes?