Discussion Underrated Pornstar(s), Overrated Pornstar(s) & Why

hotdog_6961

Tier 1 Sub
Dec 30, 2022
3
147
380
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Please, Log in or Register to view quotes

Great shout on Mischa Brooks. She was fantastic and knew how to ride a dick. I also agree Abella Danger is very overrated. I liked her at first but then she just seemed to be everywhere.

On that same note...

Overrated: Angela White
Yea I get it, she has big tits. She seems to be everywhere and her scenes don't really do it for me.

Underrated: Lola Foxx
No idea what happened to her, I know she gained some weight by the end of her career but she had that cute teen look with a bubble butt down, and don't feel like she really ever broke out as too popular.
 

mexdragon316

Tier 1 Sub
Dec 3, 2022
6
118
380
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Under:
- Molly Little (Love her eyes and I think she has a good chance of having a good career)
- Pristine Edge (There's not a lot of MILFs right now who have her body type)
- Siri Dahl (In my eyes, one of the most versatile actresses right now)
- Octavia Red (Smoking hot body and very nice tits, also I like her acting)
- Bunny Colby (There's something about her resting bitch face that makes me crazy)

Over:
- Maitland Ward (I don't get her whole "I'm a Hollywood actress" and being treated like royalty when her most memorable gig was being like 15 minutes in White Chicks. Also I think she exaggerates a lot in her scenes)
- Riley Reid (I didn't get the hype)
- Dani Daniels (I find her very attractive, but I feel her acting uninspiring)
- Kendra Sunderland (I liked her more before she went full bimbo)
- Brandi Love (Also I didn't get the hype)
 

Pictogram

Fan
Jul 7, 2022
6
68
325
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Overrated:


Mia Malkova - Looked much better a decade ago.
Mia Khalifa - Only popular because she did a hijab video. Funny thing is she has a Maronite Christian background.

Violet Myers - I don't understand why she is so popular.

Angela White - I don't get it.

Underrated:

Liz Jordan - Amazing enthusiastic performer.
 

Davejo

Diamond Tier
Oct 25, 2023
83
752
682
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Overrated: Sara Jay (I don't get what is so special about her.)
Sara_Jay_at_Exxxotica_New_York_2009_Resized.jpg


Underrated: Rilynn Rae
Sonic-Rilynn-Rae-2032-Edit-1000sRGB100.jpg
 

dnz

Fan
Mar 12, 2022
5
74
325
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
over:
Eliza Ibarra (don't like her face)
Lasirena (don't like her performance)
Mia Khalifa (even if i really like her bj and tits)
Phoenix Marie (never liked her)
Valentina Nappi (nothing special imho)
Abella Danger (don't like her face)
Savannah Bond (liked her performance only at the start)
Lily Lou (she ruined herself with surgery)
Victoria June (same)
Canela Skin (boring)
Kali Roses (she was performing better when she was thin)
Tommy King (she's getting boring)
Lisa Ann (honestly she was good but I don't like her so much)
Angela White
Riley Reid (nice bj but nothing else for me)


under:
Violet Starr
Alexis Rodriguez (great face, body and ass above all, back in the days)
Kimber Lee (idk why LOL)
Ariella Ferrera (so hot even if I don't really like her boobs 100%, her bj are awesome)
Sydney Cole (lovely ass, performances and her moanings were horny af)
Abella Anderson (she was like the best rider imho)
Carmen Caliente (great ass and body and i like her happiness in general LOL)
Katrina Moreno
Karlee Grey
Skylar Vox (when thin)
 

drdd75

Superfan
May 16, 2023
30
507
739
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
overrated: I feel like there's no point of listing my overrated ones cuz most of my opinions align with most already listed here. I will say real quick, I'm okay with Angela White but 3-peating as female POTY winner was overkill. Riley Reid and Mia Khalifa are the ones that make you pull your hair out "for the love of GOD I will never understand it how they got big..." like how sway?

Anyways, for the underrated ones. I listed a lot of ebony/black stars here because let's just be honest, they don't get the recognition they deserve at all and it's always been so frustrating to find ebony goddesses that get a lot of good work, recognition and popularity. I think it's gotten better over the last several years but could still be better. In general my overall list is focused on more recent years of the industry, some from the old days but not as many cuz I couldn't fit them all.

underrated:
Carmela Clutch (the GOAT imo)
Scarlit Scandal
Alexis Rodriguez AKA Miss Rican (miss her so much)
Avery Jane
Ashlyn Peaks
Scarlett Alexis (rising star who deserves so much more recognition imo)
Goldie Glock/Rush/Ortiz (the one underrated Latina I was obsessed with)
Diamond Banks
Cassidy Banks
Cecilia Lion
Serena Ali
Alina Ali
Adriana Maya
Willow Ryder
Jessica Ryan
Jada Stevens (in her prime)
Sheena Ryder
Alex Coal
Dharma Jones (I feel like for what she's accomplished so far, she should have way more scenes, very talented)
Crystal Chase
Layton Benton
Sasha Pearl
Alison Tyler
Alyx Star
Jeena Ivory
Jezebeth
Eve Marlowe
Aubree Valentine
Rahyndee James
Bella Rolland
Addie Andrews
Abby Cross
Ana Foxxx
Brianna Bourbon
Heather Vahn
Nicole Doshi
Penny Barber
Pepper XO
Luna Silver
Lola Bulgari
Lacy Lennon
Vicky Chase
Zoey Sinn
 

RambleTop

Bathwater Drinker
Mar 13, 2022
28
1,470
1,237
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Someone who is Overrated is that Shrooms Q girl. I do not understand the appeal of her. She is super underweight, with a flat chest and a long back with no ass. She also has some of the worst tattoos I have seen on a porn star in a while. She has a blacked out heart with horns on her ass and badly tattooed thorns or some shit on her hands.
 

thurman__merman

Facial Enthusiast
Aug 13, 2022
278
9,452
1,308
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Underrated - many of them, but I wanna give a shout out to Nicole Kitt. Stunning ebony, and a great performer ( a lot of black girls are underrated, unfortunately). I don't think I see her around enough.

Overrated - Bridgette B. She's been around for a while and I admit I don't remember her very early scenes, but everytime I see her (which is a lot, she's all over JulesJordan, EvilAngel, NaughtyAmerica, Brazzers, etc.) she just has this basic bimbo look and a resting bitch face like she doesn't care. Also, a cum hater: haven't ever seen her taking a proper facial or swallow, she always dribbles everyting out with that blank stare of hers.
 

Aguyand

Fan
Mar 16, 2022
3
99
380
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Overrated: Violet Meyers - her whole thing is blow jobs and deepthroating. She can’t actually deepthroat, it’s just the overly sloppy noisy stuff with no actual skill, and she can’t take dick. Her ass looks great but she can’t do anything with it. She’s basically a start fish in every scene. She’s all aesthetic with below average skill. You can also tell she doesn’t like porn that much and has been working on an exit plan for a while.

Underrated: Veronica Leal - She’s a beast. All three holes and gives insane energy in every scene. You can tell she loves the work.
 

kamelotawaits

Fan
Oct 23, 2023
4
80
328
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Please, Log in or Register to view quotes

Malkova lost the plot when she blew herself up. I like her paid videos with Viking Barbie but she's just not the same.

As for overrated folks:
Londer River
Gina Valentina - she's just so mid. Kinda boring. Can't think of a scene she really did that was all that good to be honest.
Lauren Phillips for sure. Her and London really started packing on the lbs. It's obvious they got lazy, and it even shows in their scenes.
Lasirena - I like her, but I can see how people think she's overrated. Sometimes it seems like she's all in, other times it's like she's phoning it in.
Abigail Mac is another one who just doesn't do it for me. I was into her originally but she went and had all kinds of work done. meh
Rachael Cavalli - doesn't really have an interesting scene in a while.
Iliza Ibarra - She just does nothing for me. I don't understand the hype
Spencer Scott - Used to like her when she first hit. Her scenes have been hit or miss. Another one who added the lbs and started phoning it in
Kendra Sunderland - whoever said that earlier. Agree. She ruined herself with all the tats in my opinion. First few scenes hot af, went downhill quickly.
Coco Lovelock - whoever mentioned her I agree. These barely legal petite looking girls who look like they're minors don't do it for me
Kenzie Reevs - same reason as Coco. These anorexic looking girls don't do it for me
Dacie Dolce - Liked her at first but she's another who has been doing really mid scenes for years

Underrated
Melody Marks - I agree with whoever said that.
Penny Barber - I really don't think she's made a bad scene.
Bella Rolland - this chick is fire. All natural too
Lacy Lennon - that girl is fking fire! Every scene. Her scenes with Vanna Bardot, Olive Glass, and Becky Bandini are my favs
Gia Derza - doesn't matter who she works with, she makes a great scene and seems to enjoy it

Personal favs
Kenzie Taylor
Romi Rain
Jaclyn Taylor
Alix Lynx
Lexi Luna
Reagan Foxx
Becky Bandini
Lena Paul
Emily Addison
 
Last edited:

Sexy_452

Casual
Aug 11, 2022
1
29
328
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
i think Mia Khalifa is 100% overrated. Im just meh about her body, and her face is kinda meh too. I just dont understand the hype. Because of how short her career was she unfortunately just had the most basic videos too. Same with this morgpie chick that's taking over twitch, she has a nice bod but there's others i would rather watch

IMO Karlee gray is underrated. She's only in 101 place on PH. She should be in the top 25. Hell i would put her at #1
 

charlie0737

Tier 3 Sub
Mar 24, 2022
7
379
530
0fya082315al84db03fa9bf467e3.png
Redhead Milfs:

Overrated: Lauren Phillips
Underrated Alternative: Siri Dahl

I can't tell you the amount of chances I have given Lauren Phillips, but there are things about her that are just boner killers; her "acting skills" are very much lacking/overacted and comes across as awkward, has a decent enough body but not a huge fan of her breasts or those teeth, (similarly to Kayley Gunner) her face is often stiff and lacks emotion a lot of the time. Also her voice just does nothing for me.

Whereas Siri (despite the boob scars) is completely the opposite! She has natural and more down to earth acting skills, is all-natural (despite the boob reduction) body wise, cute/hot as hell with that almost elf-ish nose, seems to genuinely enjoy herself more and it comes across in her eyes and face. Her scenes just seem to flow more. Severely underrated!

Please, Log in or Register to see links and images
Lauren Phillips
Please, Log in or Register to see links and images
Siri Dahl