Maimy and Puffin are the two best nsfw ASMR performers and they're challenging to rank because they both excel in very different ways.
Puffin shows more of her body which is great, but she also seems very reluctant to show her body AND face in the same video. Which means you're limited to watching either a close up of her body which feels like normal porn or a non-nude asmr video that feels almost youtube tame. On the other hand, Maimy refuses to show nudity but she is mostly "fully available" in her videos, meaning you will see her face, her body, and usually a coherent roleplay of quality varying from average to great in a single video which results in a superior viewing experience imho.
Maimy's body is also so very different from Puffin's that they're hard to compare. Puffin is a gym-crafted, surgically enhanced, "pornstar-like" sex object that is amazing to look at, but seems VERY frustrating to me because I'm so used to bodies like that being on full display instead of being hidden. The whole "I got implants, and I'm a sex worker, but I'm hiding my nipples" thing is beyond frustrating. On the other hand, Maimy has a body that if she was in street clothes probably wouldn't even get noticed by me, she is not very well "toned", but it makes her body seem especially natural, and simultaneously "obtainable" and "special". In the same way that Puffin's body seems crafted at great time and expense for our viewing pleasure (which makes her restrictions frustrating), Maimy's body being so natural and not manipulated for consumption makes us getting to view it feel like a special treat imho. For me, this again makes Maimy superior.
I think they both have the best actual ASMR skills and production quality in the genre, and either will be hard to replace in that regard. Good ASMR, with good equipment and a beutiful woman is very rare, in spite of all the complaining people do.
Thanks for coming to my TedTalk.
