I'm no great looking guy, but I'm not homely either. Beyond just going by appearance, they've just become boring and predictable. I'm not here to say they should do anything different, but if they want to continue to grow their viewership and "brand" they must bring in new talent and do different things. Such as more couple swaps or Jill doing other guys one on one. Otherwise there's no reason really to continue watching or buying/subscribing to their content. They have to either grow or retire. That child of theirs will eventually realize what's going on...and a choice will have to be made.